In 1989, however, the nature and promise of future Cromwell Days was far from settled. On a Dec. 8, 1989, typewritten memo to the planning committee, Riddell scribbled a simple question: “Repeat it?”21
For guidance, President Dunn turned to the Committee on Academic Priorities (CAP) and the Committee on Community Policy (CCP). Composed of eight professors and three administrators—two of whom were nonvoting—CAP was charged with reviewing “the curriculum and the policies of all administrative and faculty committees in matters of educational policy.”22 Populated by students, staff, faculty, alums, and Northampton community leaders, the CCP’s mandate was to “encourage diversity, free intellectual inquiry, and responsible attitudes toward the large issues of the day.”23 The committees deliberated among their own members and consulted others on questions of timing and scope: Should the event be held annually or every other year? Should it take place in the fall or be combined with Rally Day during the spring semester? Should the focus be on racism or should it be expanded to include other forms of discrimination?
CAP recommended that Cromwell Day take place every other year and be combined with Rally Day.24 The CCP advised an annual fall event of expanded scope. A memo to President Dunn formally explained, “The observance should emphasize the companion themes of (1) resisting discrimination in all of its forms and (2) celebrating diversity in all of its forms. We intend by this recommendation that the spirit of Otelia Cromwell Day will embrace the full range of discrimination and diversity acknowledged by the college’s Civil Rights Policy and Nondiscrimination Statement, without losing the concerns and goals of racial and cultural diversity specified by the Smith Design for Institutional Diversity.”25
On Nov. 16, 1990, President Dunn communicated to the CCP that “the plan to put Otelia Cromwell Day and Rally Day together isn't working … too many objections.” She did, however, request that Cromwell Day take place in the spring.26 Dunn accepted the recommendation to broaden the scope of the program. Hence, that academic year’s Cromwell Day took place on Feb. 12, 1991, and focused on “building a community characterized by an appreciation for differences in race, class, religion, and sexual orientation.” Like the first Cromwell Day, this one featured a panel discussion. Workshops focused on broad topics such as issues of oppression, religious pluralism, classism, homophobia, and heterosexism. A concert by the Harlem Spiritual Ensemble closed the day.27
At its debriefing meeting on April 30, 1991, the CCP recognized that “The first Otelia Cromwell Day was organized as a response to student demands for a mandatory class in racism after episodes of racial harassment which occurred on campus. There was some concern that last year’s program was too broad-based and should return to a symposium exclusively dealing with the issue of racism.”28 Meeting notes also recorded a suggestion to rename the day because it “no longer deals exclusively with racial issues.”29
Ultimately, the CCP decided to retain the name unless Dunn objected, and recommended that Cromwell Day be observed annually in the fall.30 The Oct. 3, 1991, celebration featured a keynote speech by linguist, educator, and actor Doris Leader Charge (Lakota) on “Preserving and Transmitting Native American Culture.” Workshops covered topics with titles such as “A Puerto Rican Reading of West Side Story,” “Perspectives of a Lesbian Alumna,” and “A Jew and a Gentile in Dialogue: Being Allies for Each Other.” The evening performance starred actor and director Ossie Davis and actress Ruby Dee, who blended “music, poetry, and dramatic readings interpreting the history of the ‘minority’ experience in America.”31
Alas, racist incidents did not abate. From 1990 to 1992, students received several more notes, a decapitated doll, and a table tent calling them “trained canines of color.”32 Over the years, Cromwell Day continued to focus on understanding and confronting racism, though the aperture sometimes expanded. What had been a symposium “on racism” in 1989 became a symposium “on diversity” in 1993.33 In 1997, the planning committee chose the theme “Language and Communication Across Cultures,” and in 1998 the college invited local schoolchildren to attend a Cromwell Day on “Celebrating Children Across Cultures.” The 1998 program declared, “For more than a decade, Otelia Cromwell Day has been instrumental in challenging our community to think critically about the meaning of cultural pluralism in our society. We have confronted issues of racism, discussed the meaning of culture, and celebrated the traditions of many.”34
The Cromwell Day planning committee has always included students (drawn from Unity Organizations with the assistance of the Office of Multicultural Affairs), staff (fulfilling essential functions and offering staff perspectives), and faculty (chosen in consultation with Faculty Council). Over time, the administrative leadership moved from the Committee on Community Policy to the Office of Minority Affairs to the Center for Religious and Spiritual Life, and eventually, to the Office for Equity and Inclusion. Occasionally, leaders from other units have been called to chair in times of need. For instance, Dean of the Smith College School for Social Work Marianne Yoshioka led the committee in 2018.
Typically, the Cromwell Day Committee begins its work each March by assessing the campus climate and trying to anticipate what the community might need by November. Deciding on a theme usually precedes identifying a keynote speaker. For instance, in 2022, the college’s renewed focus on racial literacy led to the theme “Ignorance Is Not Bliss: The Necessity of Teaching and Learning About Race.” Crystal Fleming, the author of How to Be Less Stupid about Race and now a professor at Smith, addressed this theme directly in her keynote speech. Recognizing the impact of the Israel-Palestine conflict in 2025, the committee invited Farah Pandith ’90, an international diplomat known for her bridge-building work.35
Through the years, Cromwell Day speakers have represented many different fields of expertise and held diverse identities.
Despite earlier requests, the decision to cancel classes all day to make time for expanded programming did not happen until 2020.36 Beginning that year, the planning committee scheduled wellness events in the morning such as “rest to rise” programs by Professor Benita Jackson, poster sessions to share data from campus climate surveys, and updates on equity and inclusion work at Smith, as well as other workshops. Plenary sessions continued to take place after lunchtime; workshops were offered in the afternoon; and artistic performances ended the day. Since then, Smith has continued with a daylong schedule of programming.
21Memo from Tom Riddell to the Otelia Cromwell Symposium on Racism Planning Committee, 8 Dec. 1989, box 2, Tom Riddell papers, College Archives, CA-MS-01191, Smith College Special Collections, Northampton, Massachusetts.
22Code of Faculty Governance at Smith College, Aug. 1989, p. 8. https://www.google.com/url?client=internal-element-cse&cx=013060085753386553107:qfvmbgt-eim&q=https://www.smith.edu/sites/default/files/media/Documents/Provost/Code_of_Faculty_Governance.pdf&sa=U&ved=2ahUKEwi1i5_17pqSAxXxGVkFHXS0Jw8QFnoECAMQAQ&usg=AOvVaw3iXc8j_A0-oLxU4jL_-pR0&arm=e&fexp=121491260,121491258
23Committee on Community Policy, “Report to the Smith Community on Efforts to Promote Racial Awareness,” Apr. 1987.
24Memo from Robert Merritt to Mary Maples Dunn, 2 May 1990, box 182, folder 9, Office of the President Mary Maples Dunn Files, College Archives, CA-MS-00073, Smith College Special Collections, Northampton, Massachusetts.
25Memo from the Committee on Community Policy to Mary Maples Dunn, 28 Feb. 1990, box 182, folder 10, Office of the President Mary Maples Dunn Files, College Archives, CA-MS-00073, Smith College Special Collections, Northampton, Massachusetts.
26Memo from Mary Maples Dunn to Pat Skarda and Bob Merritt, 16 Nov. 1990, box 182, folder 9, Office of the President Mary Maples Dunn Files, College Archives, CA-MS-00073, Smith College Special Collections, Northampton, Massachusetts.
27Otelia Cromwell Day program 12 Feb. 1991, box 182, folder 9, Office of the President Mary Maples Dunn Files, College Archives, CA-MS-00073, Smith College Special Collections, Northampton, Massachusetts.
28CCP notes by Karen Pfeifer and Mary Martineau, 30 Apr. 1991, box 182, folder 10, Office of the President Mary Maples Dunn Files, College Archives, CA-MS-00073, Smith College Special Collections, Northampton, Massachusetts.
29Ibid.
30Ibid.
31Otelia Cromwell Symposium program, 3 Oct. 1991, box 182, folder 10, Office of the President Mary Maples Dunn Files, College Archives, CA-MS-00073, Smith College Special Collections, Northampton, Massachusetts.
32Richardson., p. 5.
33Otelia Cromwell Day Symposium program, 2 Nov. 1993, Center for Religious and Spiritual Life records, College Archives, CA-MS-1057, Smith College Special Collections, Northampton, Massachusetts.
34Otelia Cromwell Symposia program, 1–3 Nov. 1998, box 45, Center for Religious and Spiritual Life records, College Archives, CA-MS-1057, Smith College Special Collections, Northampton, Massachusetts.
35The planning committee for Cromwell Day 2025 heard, particularly from students, that our choice of Pandith as keynote speaker missed the mark. Though about a hundred community members engaged with her in a question-and-answer opportunity following the plenary session and some apologized for walking out ahead of her speech, a subsequent town hall organized by and for students indicated that more conversation is needed. To that end, I was gratified that the leaders of the town hall, Salma Baksh ‘28 and Karolina Suarez Aldarondo ‘28, met with me, presented notes, suggested actions, and listened to my brief account of the origin and purpose of Cromwell Day. They asked me how can more members of our community better understand the history and evolution of this longstanding tradition. In the spirit of transparency and shared learning, and in consultation with President Sarah Willie-LeBreton, I spent the two months in the College archives researching and drafting this account of the history of Cromwell Day.
36Summary minutes of the Committee on Academic Policy, 18 Apr. 1990, box 182, folder 9, Office of the President Mary Maples Dunn Files, College Archives, CA-MS-00073, Smith College Special Collections, Northampton, Massachusetts; memo from CCP to Mary Maples Dunn, 28 Feb. 1990, folder 10; and memo from CCP to Mary Maples Dunn, 20 Feb. 1992, folder 11.